Brick Court Chambers

Competition Appeal Tribunal dismisses £2 billion PlayStation class action against Sony

17/11/26

On 17 November 2026, the Competition Appeal Tribunal handed down unanimous judgment in Alex Neill Class Representative Limited v Sony Interactive Entertainment Europe Limited and another [2026] CAT 86. It dismissed in its entirety the opt-out collective claim brought against Sony on behalf of around 12.2 million UK PlayStation users, concerning the operation of the PlayStation digital marketplace.

The claim was first filed in August 2022 and was certified in November 2023, when it was valued at up to £5 billion. By trial, the Class Representative was seeking about £1.49 billion in damages, or about £1.97 billion with interest. It alleged that Sony had abused a dominant position in the digital distribution of PlayStation games and add-on content in two ways:

  • Exclusionary abuses: exclusive dealing, tying, and refusal to supply in not granting third parties the ability to distribute digital content on the platform.
  • Exploitative abuse: charging an excessive and unfair margin on digital sales through the PlayStation Store.

The Class Representative alleged that retail prices would have been around 20% lower without those alleged abuses.

Following a 10-week trial that ran between March and May 2026, the Tribunal found in Sony’s favour on every issue:

  • Market Definition: The Tribunal rejected the Class Representative’s proposed aftermarket, consisting solely of PlayStation games and add-on content. Rather, it found that physical games are likely to be significant substitutes, and that multi-homing and cross-platform play are material constraints on Sony’s pricing. It held, instead, that the appropriate frame of analysis was the systems market proposed by Sony, in which PlayStation competes with Xbox and Nintendo as integrated systems. The Class Representative accepted in closing that the claim would fail were such a conclusion to be reached. However, the Tribunal continued to assess dominance and abuse for completeness.
  • Dominance: The Tribunal was not satisfied that Sony was dominant on any relevant market, as a result of both the material constraints considered in  the market definition assessment, and factors such as the historic volatility in market leadership over time.
  • Exclusionary Abuse: The Tribunal held that even on the Class Representative’s own market definition, these allegations would have failed. In this regard, it found that (i) the economic counterfactual was not credible, as the alleged 20% price difference was not made out, (ii) opening the PlayStation to third-party stores would raise unresolved security concerns and require material reconfiguration of the platform, and (iii) the Class Representative’s case on exclusive dealing and tying required it to demonstrate a prior refusal to supply, and it had not done so. The Tribunal’s findings include a useful discussion of the refusal to supply case-law.
  • Exploitative Abusive: Sony’s returns, properly measured at the level of the PlayStation system as a whole, were not shown to be either excessive or unfair.

Charlotte Thomas and Firdaus Mohandas acted for Sony, led by Daniel Beard KC of Monckton Chambers, instructed by Linklaters LLP. The judgment is available here.

All members of Brick Court Chambers are self employed barristers. Any views expressed are those of the individual barristers and not of Brick Court Chambers as a whole.