Brick Court Chambers

Court of Appeal overturns BIOT Supreme Court’s decision to quash Constitution

16/11/26

In R (Mandarin) v Commissioner for the British Indian Ocean Territory [2026] BIOT CA (Civ) 1, the BIOT Court of Appeal has handed down judgment in a significant case concerning the relationship between the UK courts and the courts of overseas territories.

The case concerned a judicial review brought by four Chagossian claimants who had travelled to the uninhabited island of Ile du Coin in February 2026. The claimants, who arrived without permits and in order to establish a permanent camp, challenged the BIOT Commissioner’s decision to issue them with removal notices. In doing so, the Commissioner relied on the BIOT (Immigration) Order 2004 and section 9 of the BIOT (Constitution) Order 2004 (the “Constitution Order”), which stated that no person had the right of abode in the territory. Section 9 had previously been held lawful by a majority of the House of Lords (Lord Hoffmann, Lord Rodger and Lord Carswell) in R (Bancoult) v SSFCA (No 2) [2009] 1 AC 453 (“Bancoult (No 2)”) (Lord Bingham and Lord Mance dissenting).

On 31 March 2026, the BIOT Supreme Court (Chief Justice James Lewis KC) handed down judgment in R (Mandarin) v Commissioner for the British Indian Ocean Territory. Agreeing with the minority in R (Bancoult) (No 2), he found that s.9 of the Constitution Order was unlawful on the basis that the royal prerogative did not permit its enactment, which had had the effect of removing the Chagossians’ right of abode. He also found, in any event, that circumstances had changed (with the Treaty signed between the UK and Mauritius in 2025) such that any rationale for s.9 of the Constitution Order had now fallen away. The Chief Justice further quashed the removal notices that had been issued, finding that a fair procedure would have to be adopted for considering representations from the Claimants. They still remained on Ile du Coin illegally as they did not have the necessary permits, but any future decisions (on removal or the issuance of permits) would have to take into account all circumstances, including the potential right of abode of any Chagossian entitled to them.       

The Court of Appeal has now reversed the BIOT Supreme Court’s decision and allowed the Commissioner’s appeal in full. In doing so it held, amongst other things, that:

  1. The Chief Justice misdirected himself that the BIOT Supreme Court had jurisdiction to consider the lawfulness of section 9 of the Constitution Order (a section which provides that nobody has a right of abode in the BIOT).
  2. The Chief Justice had erred when he failed to follow relevant judgments of the UK House of Lords & Supreme Court (particularly R (Bancoult) v Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs [2008] UKHL 61 – “Bancoult No. 2”) and, instead, found that s.9 was unlawful, preferring the minority judgments in that case.
  3. The Chief Justice erred when he held that notices issued to people who had arrived unlawfully in the BIOT, directing them to leave the BIOT and to remain outside the territory until further notice, were unlawful on the grounds of procedural unfairness.

The judgment can be found here.

Yaaser Vanderman appeared for the Commissioner. Marie Demetriou KC appeared for the Commissioner at an earlier stage of proceedings.