Brick Court Chambers

Legislation governing medical training posts is lawful; medical graduates from Malta fail in Human Rights Act challenge

18/11/26

Following a full day hearing, the Administrative Court has refused permission for a group of medical students from Queen Mary University of London (Malta campus) to challenge the Medical Training (Prioritisation) Act 2026.

The applicants were British citizens who had studied at QMUL’s overseas campus in Malta and wished to take up foundation training posts in the NHS. The Government passed fast-track legislation in 2026 in order to give priority to applicants who had studied at universities in the United Kingdom and Ireland. Amongst other things, the rationale for the change was to improve workforce management in the NHS. The applicants argued that the legislation unlawfully discriminated against them within the ambit of Article 8 (the right to private life) and Article 2 of the First Protocol (the right to education).

Having reviewed the papers, Mr Justice Kimblin ordered an oral permission hearing and reserved the case to himself. Following a full day of argument, he found that: (a) the claim was not within the ambit of Article 8; (b) the claim was not within the ambit of A2P1; and (c) the difference in treatment was justified in any event. His conclusions on (c) relied on the detailed consideration given to the position of British students studying at overseas campuses by both the Secretary of State for Health and Parliament (reflected in Hansard).

Tim Johnston acted for the Secretary of State for Health in successfully resisting the claim instructed by the Government Legal Department

All members of Brick Court Chambers are self employed barristers. Any views expressed are those of the individual barristers and not of Brick Court Chambers as a whole.